Book Talk: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Posted August 10, 2016 in 2 Star Ratings, Book Reviews / Leave a comment!

Book Talk: Harry Potter and the Cursed ChildHarry Potter and the Cursed Child by J.K. Rowling
Series: Harry Potter #8
Published On: July 31, 2016
Genres: Young Adult, Fantasy
Maturity Level: Young Adult - Some violence
2 Stars
Add to Goodreads
Amazon | Book Depository | Chapters | iBooks

Based on an original new story by J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne and John Tiffany, a new play by Jack Thorne, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the eighth story in the Harry Potter series and the first official Harry Potter story to be presented on stage. The play will receive its world premiere in London’s West End on July 30, 2016.

It was always difficult being Harry Potter and it isn’t much easier now that he is an overworked employee of the Ministry of Magic, a husband and father of three school-age children.

While Harry grapples with a past that refuses to stay where it belongs, his youngest son Albus must struggle with the weight of a family legacy he never wanted. As past and present fuse ominously, both father and son learn the uncomfortable truth: sometimes, darkness comes from unexpected places.

what-I-loved

If you haven’t guessed it by the rating already this isn’t going to be a very happy review. The one thing I did like though was Draco and Scorpius. They easily stole show here. I found Scorpius to be a very lovable character and he just had such a great personality that I fell in love with him. Draco was himself more or less but you could tell he’s changed and grown out of his horrible ways. I actually really loved Draco as a character in the series and was glad he got a chance to start to redeem himself.

what-I-didn't-love

This is going to be a big list folks. The one thing I didn’t love about this book was how ridiculous it sounded. There will be spoilers below but for those of you who haven’t read it yet here’s a spoiler free version. There were some events that were made to happen during the battle of Hogwarts that we didn’t know about until now. These events led to consequences that Harry and the gang only saw 22 years later which makes sense. What doesn’t make sense if how these events happened in the first place. It just completely blew my mind about how strange it was an easily brought my review down by 2 stars. It felt like a cop out almost, a made up plot point just to extend the story a little longer. Well it didn’t fit and I didn’t like it.

Another thing that let me down was the characters. While you could tell while reading this that the writing style was very different from Jo’s, the characters should have stayed mostly the same. You should all know by now that this story is about Harry and his son Albus. Albus is a new character so we didn’t have anything to base him on from before. I was trying so hard not to compare this to the original story but when the characters are this badly off then it’s hard not to. Harry just didn’t feel like himself. He acted childish and mean and it felt like he had no fight left in him at all. I was expecting to see a grown up Harry where some things had of course changed, but this felt like a while new character. Also Ron acted like a stupid idiot all the time and Ginny’s character wasn’t developed at all. (Kind of like in the movies to be honest.) They just could have done SO MUCH more with this play and it wasn’t there.

I think one thing you should all know going into this book is that it isn’t the 8th story. I know they marketed it that way but it just wasn’t. The plot made no sense and the characters were different. There was a lot left out that could have at least been mentioned and some parts were super confusing (though they might have been less confusing acted out?). Don’t go into this believing that it’s a continuation of the story because it’s not. The story ended at book 7 and this one probably shouldn’t have even been released. It felt like a very poorly thought out fanfiction who didn’t read the books and only watched the movies. There were details lacking that should have been put in and other parts that should have been taken out completely. Very disappointing in my opinion.

View Spoiler »

who-I'd-recommend-to

I don’t think I’d recommend this to anyone really. Unless you’re a hard core HP fan and have to read it like me. If you liked the way the 7th book ending and don’t want anything ruining that then I suggest skipping this one. It didn’t really add anything to the original story.

one-line-review

This is a book that wasn’t marketed properly or does any justice to the Harry Potter series. I’m sure the play is fun to watch but it’s not important to the series at all.

cursed-child-rating

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,


6 responses to “Book Talk: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

  1. Reading this right now. I didn’t read your spoiler review (can’t wait to read all the spoiler reviews when I finish it!), but I definitely agree that some of the things just didn’t feel thought out at all. You can tell JK Rowling didn’t have her hands very heavy in it, because the creative pool from which they were getting their ideas was very shallow. I mean, only referencing things that happened when the 7 books take place – it’s like, what happened these past 20 years? Nothing? There has to be more to the HP world than those 7 books, guys! We’ll see. I’m a little over halfway at this point…

    • And there was some things that should have been mentioned but weren’t. We’re was Teddy this whole time? I thought he was around Harry all the time (according to JKR). We didn’t even hear his name. I get that the play can only be so long but it still felt like it didn’t belong with this world.

  2. I’m literally pretending that this entire book didn’t happen. It can’t coexist with my established head-canon. Plus, I found Scorpius whiney and immature. Kind of like 4th-year per-pubescent Harry, but without the redeeming features of Sirius Black, Hermoine and the Weasley twins.

    I liked Scorpius and his verbal diarrhea. Even though I’m going to pretend he’s Draco’s surrogate child with his gay lover … because I have been utterly convinced since Book 1 in my head-canon that Draco is gay. And nothing will even change that.

    • All this seems fair. I think it was a bad idea to release more content for this series, especially from someone who isn’t JK. I felt like I had to read it but then it didn’t do anything for me. I’m sure the play is cool and everything but nothing can make that plot better.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge